Answer ( 1 )


    The Bomb Didn’T Beat Japan Stalin Did?

    In the history books, it’s commonly accepted that America dropped two atomic bombs on Japan in 1945, ultimately leading to their surrender and the end of World War II. However, there is a growing debate among historians that challenges this notion – did the bombs actually defeat Japan? Or was it Stalin’s entry into the war that truly sealed Japan’s fate? In this blog post, we’ll delve into this controversial topic and explore why some experts believe that the bomb didn’t beat Japan – Stalin did. Get ready for a thought-provoking journey through history!

    Overview of the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki

    The atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki on August 6, 1945 killed between 140,000 and 226,000 people, making them the deadliest attacks in human history. The bombings were carried out by the United States as part of its campaign to defeat Japan in World War II.

    At the time, many experts believed that the bombing of Japan’s major cities – Hiroshima with a population of about 240,000 and Nagasaki with a population of about 320,000 – would end the war quickly. In fact, it took six months for Japanese forces to surrender.

    Some historians argue that if it weren’t for Stalin’s decision to invade Manchuria instead of focusing on defeating Japan proper, then the bombing may not have happened at all. The invasion led to a drawn-out war in Asia that cost more lives and caused more damage than any bomb ever dropped on Japan.

    The Effects of the Bombing

    The bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, Japan in 1945 is generally seen as the first time that nuclear weapons were used in warfare. The bombings resulted in the deaths of approximately 150,000 people. It’s been argued that the bombing didn’t actually defeat Japan, and that it was Stalin’s invasion of Manchuria which ultimately led to Japan’s capitulation. In this article, we’ll explore the claim that Stalin’s invasion was more responsible for Japan’s downfall than the bombing.

    Stalin’s invasion of Manchuria started in 1931 and lasted until 1945. During this time, he killed an estimated 20 million people, making it one of the deadliest periods in world history. The bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki may have killed 150,000 people, but Stalin’s invasion killed an estimated 20 million people too. If you divide the number of casualties by the population at the time (approximately 350 million), then Stalin’s invasion is actually four times more deadly than the bombings.

    In addition to killing millions of people, Stalin’s invasion also destroyed infrastructure and caused massive famine. This forced millions of people to flee their homes and led to a humanitarian crisis that was even worse than the bombings themselves. Ultimately, it was Stalin’s invasion which led to Japan’s surrender in 1945 rather than the bombing itself.

    The Debate over whether the Bomb Beat Japan or Stalin Did

    The debate over whether the bomb beat Japan or Stalin did has lasted for many years. In 1945, Hiroshima was hit by an atomic bomb, an event that caused untold devastation and led to the deaths of over 200,000 people. Many believe that the bomb helped to bring about Japan’s capitulation, whereas others maintain that it was Stalin who ultimately forced Japan to surrender.

    The reality is that it is impossible to say for certain which factor – the bombing of Hiroshima or Stalin’s policies – played a more significant role in ending World War II. However, what is clear is that without both weapons being used, the war would likely have continued for many more months or even years.


    It’s been argued that the atomic bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki didn’t actually defeat Japan, it was instead Soviet dictator Joseph Stalin who won World War II. Stalin’s forces invaded Manchuria in 1945, which led to the surrender of Japan on August 15th. The bombings may have hastened Japan’s capitulation, but without Stalin’s invasion there is a good chance that the Japanese would have surrendered sooner or later anyway.

Leave an answer